Culinary Experts Weigh In On Whether Tomatoes Need Deseeding

Quick Brief
Culinary experts have weighed in on the common kitchen dilemma of whether tomatoes need to be deseeded. According to the panel, the necessity of removing seeds depends entirely on the tomato variety and the intended dish. While certain seedier or more bitter types benefit from deseeding, others are better left intact.
What Happened?
A panel of culinary experts discussed the practice of deseeding tomatoes for various recipes. Rachel Roddy noted that certain varieties, such as Sicilian tomatoes grown with little water, contain bitter seeds that should be removed by flicking or sieving. Conversely, Jay Patel explained that meaty varieties like vesuvio tomatoes used for salads do not require deseeding. For sauces, Patel stated that slow-cooked sauces utilize tinned tomatoes with seeds included, whereas lighter, fresh tomato sauces call for fresh tomatoes that are blanched, peeled, and deseeded.
Why It Matters
Understanding when to deseed tomatoes helps home cooks optimize flavor and texture in their dishes. Matching the tomato variety and preparation method to the recipe prevents bitterness in certain dishes while preserving desirable moisture and acidity in others.
Key Facts
- Whether to deseed tomatoes depends on the specific variety and the recipe being prepared.
- Sicilian varieties that receive little water feature numerous bitter seeds that should be flicked or sieved out.
- Vesuvio tomatoes used in salads are meaty with few seeds, making deseeding unnecessary.
- Watery winter tomatoes can provide a desirable pop and acidity in salads if the seeds are kept.
- Slow-cooked pasta sauces typically use tinned chopped tomatoes with seeds intact, while lighter sauces often use blanched, peeled, and deseeded fresh tomatoes.
Compiled from 1 outlet
Related Stories

London Irish Rapper Kibo Discusses His Inventive Debut Album 'Kwengletaria: Ragamyff'
Rising 26-year-old London Irish rapper Kibo is drawing attention for his inventive and humorous UK rap debut, Kwengletaria: Ragamyff. Coming from Harrow—a town with little rap tradition—he has cultivated a distinct, maximalist artistic philosophy he terms Kwelengletarianism. His work has already earned co-signs from prominent UK artists such as Skepta, JME, and Dave.

San Diego Natural History Museum Offers Unique Taxidermy and Fossil Lending Program
The San Diego Natural History Museum operates a unique lending program that allows local residents to borrow real natural history specimens. Borrowers can take home items ranging from small insects and animal pelts to dinosaur fossils for up to two weeks.

New Exhibition Explores the Architectural Works of Georgia O’Keeffe
The Detroit Institute of Arts has launched a new exhibition highlighting the urban architecture and skyscraper paintings of American artist Georgia O’Keeffe. Curated by Ben Coleman, the showcase features nearly 40 works that reveal a grittier, industrial side of the artist beyond her famous flora and landscapes. The collection aims to present a fresh perspective on an iconic creator by focusing on pieces she considered essential.

Sir Richard Alston, Pioneering British Choreographer, Dies at 77
Sir Richard Alston, a leading figure in British contemporary dance known for his rigorous and musical creations, has died at the age of 77. The Richard Alston Foundation announced that he passed away peacefully at his home on September 7 following a period of ill health. Tributes have poured in from across the dance community, including from prominent figures like Akram Khan.