UK government defends £56,000 per person cost for returns under 'one in one out' France scheme

Quick Brief
The United Kingdom is spending roughly £56,000 for every individual sent back to France under its 'one in, one out' migration agreement. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood revealed the financial figure during questioning by the home affairs select committee. She defended the expenditure, asserting that the cost is comparable to or lower than housing a person in a hotel for a year.
What Happened?
During an appearance before the home affairs select committee, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood disclosed that the government's 'one in, one out' agreement with France costs approximately £56,000 for each person returned. Confronted by MPs questioning whether the arrangement provides proper value for taxpayers, the home secretary defended the high expense by arguing that it roughly matches or undercuts the cost of maintaining an individual in hotel accommodations for a full year.
Why It Matters
The disclosure highlights the steep financial realities of managing cross-border migration deals and housing asylum seekers. As lawmakers scrutinize government spending and taxpayer value, the comparative cost of deportations versus long-term domestic lodging remains a central point of debate in UK politics.
Key Facts
- The UK's 'one in, one out' return deal with France costs about £56,000 per returned individual.
- Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood revealed the figure to members of Parliament.
- The disclosure was made during a session with the home affairs select committee.
- Mahmood defended the expense by stating it is comparable to or cheaper than a year of hotel accommodation.
Compiled from 2 outlets
Related Stories

Thirlwall Inquiry Report Published Amid Ongoing Questions Over Nurse Convictions
The Thirlwall Inquiry has published its 822-page report regarding neonatal care at the Countess of Chester hospital, where a nurse was convicted of murdering and attempting to murder infants. Critics argue the inquiry should have waited for pending case reviews challenging the convictions. Nevertheless, the report offers key recommendations for NHS oversight and whistleblower support.

Noah Donohoe Inquest Finds Tunnel Errors Possibly Contributed to Death
A nine-member jury has concluded an inquest that began in January regarding the death of Noah Donohoe. The panel determined that errors related to a tunnel possibly contributed to the tragedy. The verdict follows deliberation on ten specific questions presented to the jury.

Cot Cameras Planned Across Wards Following Damning Inquiry Into Serial Killer Lucy Letby
A rigorous inquiry has concluded that certain infants targeted by serial killer Lucy Letby could have been saved. In response to the findings, urgent plans are moving forward to install live-streaming cot cameras in hospital wards.

Reform UK Welsh Leader Steps Down Following Arrest on Suspicion of Assault
The leader of Reform UK in Wales, Dan Thomas, has resigned from his post after being arrested and subsequently bailed. His departure follows allegations of assault and controlling or coercive behavior. The announcement also coincided with another Reform Senedd member defecting to Plaid Cymru.